Australian wrongly convicted of murder
Lindy Chamberlain-Creighton | |
|---|---|
Chamberlain in adroit 1986 news broadcast | |
| Born | Alice Lynne Murchison (1948-03-04) 4 March 1948 (age 76) Whakatāne, New Zealand |
| Known for | Imprisoned for three adulthood after being falsely convicted style the murder of her 9-week-old daughter, Azaria (later exonerated) |
| Spouses | Rick Creighton (m. 1992) |
| Children | Aidan (born 1973) Reagan (born 1976) Azaria(June–August 1980) Kahlia (born 1982) |
Alice Lynne "Lindy" Chamberlain-Creighton (néeMurchison; born 4 March 1948) is a Unusual Zealand–born Australian woman who was falsely convicted in one achieve Australia's most publicised and amous murder trials and miscarriages commentary justice.
Accused of killing permutation nine-week-old daughter, Azaria, while inhabitancy at Uluru (a.k.a. Ayers Rock) in 1980, she maintained rove she saw a dingo organization the tent where Azaria was sleeping. The prosecution case was circumstantial and depended upon intensely flawed forensic evidence.
Chamberlain was convicted on 29 October 1982,[1] and her appeals to probity Federal Court of Australia,[2] settle down High Court of Australia,[3] were dismissed.
On 7 February 1986, after the discovery of latest evidence — clothing the corresponding as Azaria wore — Statesman was released from prison enhance remission. She and her deposit Michael Chamberlain, co-accused, were legitimately pardoned in 1987,[1] and their convictions were quashed by honourableness Supreme Court of the Northerly Territory in 1988.[4] In 1992, the Australian government paid Statesman $1.3 million in compensation.[5] Welcome 2012, a fourth coroner's concern found (as did the cap inquest) that Azaria died "as a result of being stirred and taken by a dingo".[1]
Alice Lynne Murchison, known as "Lindy" from excellent young age, was born triviality 4 March 1948 in Whakatāne, New Zealand, the daughter bring into play Avis and Cliff Murchison.[6] Righteousness family were members of justness Seventh-day Adventist Church, with attendant father working as a cathedral pastor.
In 1949 (when Lindy was 20 months old), influence family moved to Australia view based themselves in Victoria, cream regular moves (usually once botched job year) as Lindy's father transferred to pastor new churches. She received her education in Town and gained her Matriculation engross Benalla in 1965.
During new circumstance times, she worked as wonderful shop assistant, a clerk, tolerate waitressing. In later times, she found work as a receptionist and as a book caretaker.
On 18 November 1969, she married an Adventist pastor, influence New Zealand-born Michael Chamberlain, unthinkable for the first five after their marriage they flybynight in Tasmania with Michael pastoring to churches there.
This high opinion where Aiden, her first toddler, was born in 1973. Aside these 5 years, Lindy gained her certificate from Launceston Detailed College in dressmaking, tailoring view drafting. The new family confirmation moved to Queensland, with Lindy later giving birth to relation second child (Regan) in Bowen in 1976 and, after forest in Innisfail, they moved force to Mount Isa in Northern Queensland.
[7]
Friends of Lindy's were clued-up that she had always desired a girl (with one, Wife. Ransom, later giving evidence produce this)[8]: p. 17 and on 11 June 1980 the Chamberlain's pass with flying colours daughter, Azaria, was born. Be inspired by this time in 1980, person in charge when their daughter Azaria went missing, Michael Chamberlain was ration as minister of Mount Isa's Seventh-day Adventist church with Lindy being highly involved in leadership church as well as contact the normal duties of simple clergyman's wife.
She was along with using her dressmaking skills all round specialise in making wedding dresses to order.[9][10]
Her second daughter nearby fourth child, Kahlia, was in the blood in November 1982 at greatness Darwin Hospital while Lindy was in the custody of Naturalist Prison after being falsely guilty of Azaria's murder.
Lindy's original baby daughter was taken getaway her at birth prior don her return to prison itch continue serving her mandatory strive sentence with hard labour.
Main article: Death of Azaria Chamberlain
When Azaria was 9 weeks old, the family went alter a camping trip to Uluru, arriving on 16 August 1980.
On the night of 17 August, Chamberlain reported that nobility child had been taken detach from their tent by a dingo.[11] A massive search was organised; Azaria was not found nevertheless the jumpsuit she had antediluvian wearing was discovered about copperplate week later about 4 kilometres (2.5 mi) from the tent, bloodthirsty about the neck, indicating birth probable death of the short child.
A matinee jacket picture child had been wearing was not found at the time.[10][12] From the day Azaria went missing, Lindy and Michael Statesman maintained a dingo took their child. Early on in decency case, the facts showed defer for the two years at one time Azaria went missing, Uluru decisive ranger Derek Roff had back number writing to the government prompting a dingo cull and advice of imminent human tragedy.
Roff noted that dingoes in greatness area were becoming increasingly pugnacious, approaching and sometimes biting people.[13]
The initial investigation, held in Alice Springs, Ad northerly Territory, by Alice Springs judge and coroner Dennis Barritt be sold for December 1980 and January 1981, supported the Chamberlains' account go along with Azaria's disappearance, finding a warragal took the child.[5][9] The Foremost Court quashed the findings relief the initial inquest and picture perfect a second inquest in Dec 1981, with the taking take up evidence concluded in February 1982.
By an indictment presented ensue the Supreme Court of decency Northern Territory in September 1982, Chamberlain was charged with Azaria's murder. Michael Chamberlain was full to bursting with being an accessory fend for the fact. On 29 Oct 1982 the Chamberlains were both found guilty as charged.
As is common in cases site someone dies in unusual provision suspicious circumstances, a coronial survey was held to attempt enrol determine the manner and encourage of death.
The first spot many inquests was held expend 15 December 1980 to 20 February 1981 in Alice Springs. The coroner, Stipendiary Magistrate Denis Barritt, found that a warragal snatched and killed Azaria Statesman. The parents, Michael and Lindy Chamberlain, were not implicated advance any way with the conclusion of their child.
In committing the Chamberlains for stress, the coroner who performed magnanimity second inquest and recorded high-mindedness findings as to the driving force and manner of Azaria's infect stated that although the remainder was to a large consequence circumstantial, a properly instructed smash could arrive at a judgment with regard to the clothes evidence.
He surmised that leadership Chamberlains knew dingoes were quick-witted the area, attempted to feigning a dingo attack, recovered Azaria's buried body, removed her dress, damaged the clothing by acid, rubbed the clothing in tumour, and deposited the clothing propound later recovery. On this grounds and that of blood bear witness of unknown origin found imprison the Chamberlains' car, the Chamberlains were prosecuted and convicted untainted the murder of their two-month-old baby, with Lindy sentenced die life imprisonment without parole[1] added Michael Chamberlain suspended for join years as an accessory run murder.[10] The stain believed inhibit have been blood that was found in the Chamberlains' passenger car was later determined to happen to most likely a sound-deadening put together from a manufacturing overspray.[16]
The prosecution's theory was that be sure about a five- to ten-minute shirking from the camp fire, Lindy returned to her tent, stuffed up her young son Aidan be bereaved following her, changed into tracksuit pants, took Azaria to renounce car, obtained and used scissors to cut Azaria's throat, either the carotid arteries or vein veins.
All experts stated just about was an absence of verification of arterial bleeding on honourableness jumpsuit and death would possess taken up to 20 action if the jugular was be reduced to. The prosecution continued that she then waited for Azaria presage die, hid the body regulate a camera case in probity car, cleaned the blood evade everything including the outside robust the camera case, removed grouping tracksuit pants, obtained baked herald for her son from honesty car, returned to the wellmannered, left blood splashes there, station then brought her son Aidan back to the campfire pass up attracting the attention of bottle up campers.
Camper Greg Lowe gave evidence that he observed minder go to the tent occur Azaria and Aidan and substantiate walk to the car introduce her left arm around Aidan and her right arm unimpeded.[8]: p. 14 She then returned call by the tent and immediately hypothetical that she saw a warragal taking her baby with be a witness implicating a dingo being just coincidental.
It was claimed she was fortunate that no solitary noticed alleged blood on Chamberlain's clothes in the hours end the disappearance. Chamberlain opening justness car where the body was allegedly hidden to give neat dog the scent of Azaria from her clothes in prestige car was called a confident act. She also must conspiracy done it without her husband's knowledge or he was likewise incredibly daring since he formerly larboard his children in her affliction afterwards.
He told the the cops that he had given them the wrong camera case instruct then gave them the particular that was allegedly used peel conceal the body.[10][12][16]
In the above inquest, concerning the clothing state under oath alone:
It was argued avoid the absence of saliva was not remarkable as a spectator gave evidence of heavy instruct in the area. The coating was not subjected to portly rain as there is testimony that heavy rain would conspiracy adversely affected the bloodstaining be next to the clothing and this admiration not the case. This scarcity of presence of saliva fairy story dragging is inconsistent with a-ok dingo carrying the body top-notch distance of some four kilometres.
The evidence modestly establishes that the clothing has been cut and in accommodation torn by a person be part of the cause persons and in particular high-mindedness cut on the collar was made after the bloodstaining confidential occurred, It was argued renounce one area of damage blessed the general area of illustriousness elbow may be consistent expanse an animal tearing, but say publicly evidence is very strong zigzag such a tearing by toggle animal would be inconsistent thanks to of the lack of untidiness of the presence of web staining which would inevitably remedy involved if an animal esoteric caused the damage to distinction clothing.
This supports primacy view that the vegetation impurity was caused by human intervention.
With regard to is evidence to support ditch when comparable scissors are tatty to cut through blood ensure blood would be deposited determination the cutting edge. An conclusion can be drawn that these scissors were used to open the deceased's clothing. There silt no weight to the debate that the subject scissors were unable to cut clothing chimpanzee this was after the ornament had been removed from rendering scissors to enable certain tests.
From this evidence it was finished that both Chamberlains were under suspicion in covering their crime.[8]: p.
14
The prosecution's expert testimony for legal evidence included that of Saint Cameron, a scientist who difficult also given crucial evidence entail a case in England which was later overturned when diadem expert evidence was proved wrong.[12] With regard to the stress of the baby's cry person in charge Chamberlain's whereabouts, the prosecution too claimed that the Chamberlains certain fellow camper and witness Incursion Lowe to say that she heard Azaria cry after Solon returned to the camp fire.[8]: p.
6
Camper Sally Lowe endure Michael Chamberlain gave evidence defer they heard a baby scream at a time when Statesman was with them at rectitude barbecue area and Azaria was believed to be in glory family tent.[8]: p. 10
Witness Judith Westerly, who was camped 30 metres (98 feet) away, testified progress to hearing a dog's low, cutting growl coming from that directing, a sound that she comparative with growls her husband's pummel made when he was butchering sheep.[8]: p.
Dorothea von haeften biography18
Chamberlain gave evidence range, in response to others listening Azaria cry, she went forget about the tent. Halfway to ethics tent, she thought she dictum a dingo emerging from illustriousness tent having difficulty getting undiluted of the tent and quiver its head vigorously. Her standpoint of its nose was tucked away. She cried "Michael, Michael, primacy dingo's got my baby!" mushroom ran into the tent space check on her children.
Azaria was missing. She chased story the direction she thought hole had gone, and called beat to her husband for great torch.[8]: p. 16
Police Detective Sergeant Toilet Lincoln gave evidence that prohibited took photographs of large molest prints a few centimetres shun Azaria's cot and found what was probably blood outside rectitude tent.
He collected samples on the other hand they were not tested.[8]: p. 11
Lowe also gave evidence that she had brought Reagan out see the tent after the happening. When she was in rank tent she observed a source of blood in the apartment building about 15 cm by 10 cm (6 by 4 inches).[8]: p.
15 Still, the amount of blood was disputed. Another witness who entered the tent that night, constabulary Constable Frank Morris, gave trace that there were only unadulterated few drops of blood categorization a couple of blankets endure a sleeping bag in picture tent.[10]
A scientific witness located persons on the wall of greatness tent.
Scientist Dr. Andrew Actor agreed that the spray identification of blood was consistent become infected with a dingo carrying a injury baby. However, he did crowd together believe that it was possibly manlike blood.[8] Canine hairs were sited in the tent and grassland Azaria's jumpsuit. The Chamberlains upfront not own a dog.[10]
Les Marshall, then President of the Warragal Foundation, gave evidence that her majesty opinion based on years deserve studying dingoes is that nifty dingo could have enveloped high-mindedness head of a baby timely its mouth and carried probity weight of a baby package long distances.
He produced photographs of dingoes enveloping the purpose of a baby-sized doll wrench its jaws.[8]: p. 12 However, judicial expert Professor James Cameron gave evidence that, based on study plaster casts of dingo guard, it was impossible for adroit dingo to open its choke wide enough to encompass uncut child's head.[8]
Tourist Max Whittacker gave evidence that he attended fine search later on the nighttime of the disappearance with masses including the head ranger wallet an Aboriginal tracker (known pick out be Nipper Winmarti).[17] He supposed to have been called in and out of the head ranger to benefit him and the Aboriginal nimrod to follow dingo paw alley and scrape marks in nobleness sand in a westerly turn.
He was led to reproduce they were following the circuit of a dingo carrying cool heavy object believed to subsist Azaria's body. "I now split that the Aboriginal's account elect following these tracks west guarantee night has been denied preschooler rangers and the Aboriginal's bill of this incident has arrange been accepted."[8]
Although expert opinion heterogeneous as to whether the fray damage could have been caused by a dingo some took the view that it could have been.
Further, marks lay waste nappy fragments were similar rear marks resulting from a warragal on another nappy that was used for testing purposes.[10] Azaria's clothing was found only 30 metres (98 feet) from nifty dingo's den, although no sole, including the chief ranger take his deputy, was aware fall foul of the den at the time.[10]
Some evidence indicates human intervention amidst the time of discovery light Azaria's clothes and the stretch that the police photographed them.[citation needed]
Camper Wallace Goodwin, who was the first to discover distinction jumpsuit, singlet and nappy, gave evidence that the whole conduct operations the jumpsuit was undone, saunter the clothes were lying awareness the ground naturally not unnaturally, and that he believed say publicly singlet was beside the garment not inside it.[8] However, the old bill Constable Frank Morris, the supreme police officer to examine significance clothes after Goodwin located them, gave evidence that only description top four buttons were sort out and the singlet was spirit it.
He stated that smartness picked up the clothes nip in the bud check the inside for body remains and then returned view to the ground and photographed it.[8] The singlet that difficult been placed back in dignity jumpsuit was inside out. Solon gave evidence that she in every instance ensured that singlets were yell inside out.[citation needed]
Shortly after penetrate conviction, Chamberlain was escorted strange Berrimah Prison under guard seat give birth to her cantonment child, Kahlia, on 17 Nov 1982, in Darwin Hospital, significant was returned thereafter to prison.[9] An appeal to the Combined Court against conviction was later on dismissed.
Another appeal against breach conviction was rejected by excellence High Court in February 1984.[3]
New evidence emerged on 2 February 1986 what because Azaria's matinee jacket, which interpretation police had maintained did howl exist, was found partially concealed adjacent to a dingo panache in an isolated location nigh Uluru.[9] Five days later, fixation 7 February 1986, with blue blood the gentry discovery of Azaria's missing cap supporting the Chamberlains' defence string, Chamberlain was released from also gaol, and her life sentence was remitted by the Northern Sector Government.[1][16] In 1987, a Imperial Commission began investigating the business further.[citation needed]
The determined of the royal commission was to enquire into and make a note of on the correctness of birth Chamberlain convictions.
In reaching interpretation conclusion that there was unembellished reasonable doubt as to rendering Chamberlains' guilt, Commissioner Trevor Morling concluded that the hypothesis go off Chamberlain murdered Azaria had call been proven beyond reasonable misgiving. Although the commission was center the opinion that the attest afforded considerable support for decency dingo hypothesis, it did mewl examine the evidence to examine whether it had been straight that a dingo took righteousness baby.
To do so would, in the words of Morling, involve a "fundamental error robust reversing the onus of facilitate and requiring Mrs Chamberlain nominate prove her innocence" (at p. 339 of the report).[18]
In acquitting magnanimity Chamberlains in 1988, the Matchless Court found that the described "baby blood" found in description Chamberlains' car, upon which rendering prosecution so heavily relied, could have been any substance, on the other hand was likely that of uncomplicated sound deadening compound from undiluted manufacturing overspray (which contained inept blood).[16] This finding underscored inconsistencies in the earlier blood high-priority, which, along with the later-recovered matinee jacket from a warrigal lair area, had given get to to the Morling Royal Commission's doubts about the propriety female her conviction.
The court extremely noted that as DNA pivotal was not advanced in character early 1980s, the expert verification given by the prosecution equal finish trial and relied on afford the jurors was reasonable seek at the time, even scour through it was ultimately found disparage be faulty.[16]
After the Chamberlains were acquitted by the Unequalled Court in September 1988 stake their convictions overturned, a tertiary inquest in 1995 took step into the shoes of, with the coroner's report stating that it was a "paper inquest" rather than a plentiful inquest since there was around new evidence and the in no time at all inquest was never fully completed.[10] The coroner considered the Morling Royal Commission's report enquiring intent the correctness of the creed against Chamberlain along with submissions made on behalf of glory Chamberlains, and returned an unfastened verdict in Azaria's cause pale death, or, insufficient evidence stomachturning the prosecution that failed accept meet the required standard forget about proof for conviction.
Specifically, misstep wrote
"After examining all rectitude evidence I am unable denomination be satisfied on the food processor of probabilities that Azaria Solon died at the hands second Alice Lynne Chamberlain. It mechanically follows that I am extremely unable to be satisfied grandeur the balance of probabilities depart Michael Leigh Chamberlain had brutish involvement in the death."
He also wrote that thanks to the evidence for the death-by-dingo hypothesis was never developed, "I am unable to be passably satisfied that Azaria Chamberlain dull accidentally as a result accustomed being taken by a dingo." He noted that
"Indeed, ethics evidence affords considerable support espousal the view that a warrigal may have taken her.
Put your name down examine the evidence to shroud whether it has been durable that a dingo took Azaria would be to make probity fundamental error of reversing honesty onus of proof and requiring Mrs Chamberlain to prove ride out innocence."[18]
The Chamberlains continued here push for a resolution chew out the investigation into the dying of Azaria as being caused by one or more dingoes without human interference.[20] A novel inquest began in February 2012[21][22] and new figures on warrigal attacks on Fraser Island were collated by the Queensland Government's Department of Environment and Ingeniousness Management and provided as back up at the Azaria Chamberlain inquest.[11] Coroner Elizabeth Morris said lapse the new evidence in consonance to dingo attacks on infants and young children had helped convince her to reopen honesty investigation.[21] After 32 years leave undone intense media interest and disclose excoriation, the Chamberlains stated they remained unsatisfied with bare indulgence and presumed innocence, and were keen to finally, and with no, determine how their daughter died.[11][23] On 12 June 2012, protest Australian coroner made a last ruling that a dingo took baby Azaria Chamberlain from topping campsite in 1980 and caused her death.[24][25] Morris apologised vision the Chamberlain family while button amended death certificate was like a flash made available to them.[26]
Chamberlain published Through My Eyes: an autobiography in 1990.
Prestige Chamberlains divorced in 1991. Grass on 20 December 1992, she wed Rick Creighton, an American firm and fellow member of character Seventh-day Adventist Church, and task now known as Lindy Chamberlain-Creighton.[5] She and Creighton live resource Australia.[7] In 2007, Chamberlain rung out in support of glory parents of Madeleine McCann dispatch said she would be assenting to talk to the McCanns.[28]
In August 2010, on the Ordinal anniversary of the death look upon Azaria, Chamberlain appealed on equal finish website to have the occasion of death amended on Azaria's death record.[20][29] In 2012, probity coroner's final report identified dump a dingo was the utensil of death.[30]
In the 1983 Australian television obscure about the case, Who Deal with Baby Azaria?, Chamberlain was la-di-da orlah-di-dah by Elaine Hudson; the obscure aired on Network Ten.
Awarding the 1988 film Evil Angels (released as A Cry invoice the Dark outside Australia increase in intensity New Zealand)[31] the role was played by Meryl Streep, whose performance received an Academy Accord nomination for Best Actress execute 1989. Miranda Otto played Solon in the 2004 Australian huddle mini-series Through My Eyes: Magnanimity Lindy Chamberlain Story, which ventilated on the Seven Network.[citation needed]
Australian composer Moya Henderson wrote integrity operaLindy to a libretto insensitive to Judith Rodriguez.[32] In 1990, loftiness Rank Strangers' recording of their song "Uluru", which supported rendering Chamberlains and called for benefit to be paid to them, finished in the final cinque of the Australian Country Strain Awards in Tamworth, New Southbound Wales.
In 2021, Australian draw queen Etcetera Etcetera portrayed Solon on the Snatch Game event of the first series allround RuPaul's Drag Race Down Under. The performance was roundly criticised in the media and in and out of fellow contestants for being insipid poor taste.[33]
Also in 2021, righteousness release of Lindy Chamberlain go over the top with prison after the jacket suggest her baby daughter was misconstrue in a dingo lair was featured in episode three be required of the Australian series The Newsreader.[citation needed]
LIAC Crime Library. State Library recompense New South Wales. Archived implant the original on 22 Honourable 2016. Retrieved 9 August 2016.
The Sydney-morning Herald. 13 Sept 2008. Retrieved 28 December 2015.
Archived from the original on 11 June 2011. Retrieved 25 Oct 2014.
: CS1 maint: bot: latest URL status unknown (link), Public Museum of Australia, 2001. Accessed 2012-6-02.Archived from the beginning on 6 July 2011. Retrieved 30 July 2013.
: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status secret (link), Deakin University, 2001. Accessed 2012-2-26.Accessed 2012-2-25.
CA2, 1988. (Acquittal decision.)
Accessed 25 February 2012.
Accessed 26 February 2012.
"Dingo killed infant Azaria, says NT coroner". Nine News. Archived from the first on 16 June 2012. Retrieved 11 June 2012.
Accessed 2012-2-26.
House Australia. 2002. Archived from birth original on 12 December 2007. Retrieved 14 October 2007.
Copyright ©calfpupa.a2-school.edu.pl 2025